What is the THI?
The Temperature Humidity Index (THI) was originally developed by E.C. Thom in 1958 as a measure of human comfort and extended to cattle in 1964 by Barry et al. The thresholds of mild, moderate and severe were later defined by Whittier (1993) and Armstrong (1994). The THI threshold of 72 was always defined with the caveat that it may under-estimate heat load in high yield cows. However, the underlying reasons why this was the case were not well defined. This was due to the experimental design used in the early experiments:
- the animals were exposed to continuous environmental conditions, not the normal rise and fall of temperature and humidity that would be experienced by dairy cows in the real world.
- the effect of the environmental condition on milk yield was not measured until 2 weeks after exposure
- the cows had an average milk yield of 15 kg/day and a range of 2.7-31.8 kg/day
Many of today’s high yield dairy cows produce an average of more than 30 kg/day and up to 50 kg/day at peak production.
Revised THI thresholds
Recent research has shown that the impact of heat stress on milk yield occurs much faster and at a lower threshold than previously thought. A reduction in milk can be expected 1 to 2 days following exposure to the environmental condition above a THI threshold of 68. Avoiding a decline in milk production over a 2 day period will automatically prevent a decrease in lactation persistency two weeks later.
Bernabucci et al 2010 investigated over a million lactation records and found that milk yield losses were detectable above a THI of 68.
Collier et al 2012 found that milk yield losses become significant when the a minimum daily THI is 65 or the average daily THI is 68. They have also published a new THI threshold chart (see below) that identifies the threshold for milk yield losses and matches THI with rectal temperatures and respiratory rates.
PLEASE NOTE: these thresholds are not part of the Dairy Forecast Service and are only displayed here for educational purposes.
Bohmanova et al. 2007 and Dikmen & Hansen 2009; Dikmen et al. 2009 have shown that the THI threshold for milk yield losses differs by climatic region, local herd adaptation and cow genotype. Different thresholds suggest that the cause of heat stress is different in the different climatic regions. For example:
- In subtropical climates evaporative cooling is restricted due to higher humidity, hence heat stress is detectable at lower air temperatures than would otherwise be considered low risk in semi-arid climates
- In semi-arid climates cows can be exposed to much higher air temperatures without adverse effects, because the humidity is significantly lower
The research also suggests that in regions where evaporative cooling is not compromised, e.g. arid and semi-arid climates, air temperature alone is as good an indicator of heat stress as the THI. This may be a useful benchmark for some dairy operators to identify at what temperature they observe heat stress effect in their cows even though the current THI suggest otherwise.
Local herd adaptation is also important as cows become acclimatised to a location over time, such that cows from southern Victoria would have a different response to the environmental conditions experienced in central Queensland than cows raised there. This acclimatisation process is continuous and cows can move from being acclimatised to unacclimatised based on extended weather conditions. The details of cow acclimatisation are too broad to be covered here, however the key point is that a herds response to heat stress is related to how acclimatised they are to their climatic region.
Putting it all together
The current alert thresholds, as defined by Dairy Australia may under-estimate the effects of heat stress on dairy cows, depending on your particular circumstances. Heat stress can have a detrimental impact on milk yields much quicker and at a lower threshold and than previously thought and climatic regions and herd acclimatisation can influence milk yield losses from heat stress.
To address some of these issues Katestone and Dairy Australia introduced customised alert thresholds for subscribers to the Dairy Forecast Service. Thresholds can be set for daily maximum and average temperature and THI along with the current alert thresholds, that reflect the local knowledge and experience of the dairy operator.
For example a dairy in southeast SA observed heat stress in their cows when the daily temperature exceeded 38°C with a relative humidity of less than 10%. Using the current thresholds this condition does not trigger an alert as the THI is below 82 and it did not exceed 78 for more than 3 out the following 6 days.
With the customised alert settings this dairy can keep the traditional alerts as well as set a maximum daily temperature alert that reflects the local herd adaptations and climatic conditions at their dairy.
Bernabucci, U., Lacetera, N., Baumgard, L.H., Rhoads, R.P., Ronchi, B., Nardone, A.
2010. Metabolic and hormonal acclimation to heat stress in domestic ruminants.
Collier RJ, Hall LW, Rungruang S, Zimbleman RB (2012) Quantifying heat stress and its impact on metabolism and performance. Proceedings of ‘23rd Annual Ruminant Nutrient Symposium’, Florida, 2012.
Available at http://dairy.ifas.ufl.edu/rns/2012/6CollierRNS2012a.pdf [Verified 23 February, 2016]